In too deep…

I put my mind somewhere and apparently can’t find it. See I went to cookie exchange today, the same one I go to every year. We also do an ornament exchange on that one as well (I got a cute penguin one of the exchange). And I exchange gifts with someone there as well. Plus my friend J got me the cutest little ornament that has gingerbread cookies on a baking sheet (very me). My point being there was a lot in my hands when I left.

So much so that when I was pretty much all the way home (I do not live close by) I realized that I forgot my cookie tray there. I figured I have another cookie exchange on Saturday and the hostess of this exchange is going to that one as well (we like our cookies). But then the hostess called me while I was driving home. I was about to say I know I left my tray when she uttered very sad news…yes, I had left my tray…and ALL of my exchange cookies as well. AHHHHH. That pretty much sucks broken Christmas bulbs.

So to cheer my cookie-less self up I decided to make a holiday version of the deep dish cookie pie that I had seen on yes, Pinterest. Instead of chocolate chips I used chopped up peppermint bark…and what a good choice that was! Topped with some candy cane ice cream…screams holiday time. These are definitely best when eaten fresh out of the oven, but I plan on reheating one later and don’t see it being too much of an issue.

The good news is I can still find my computer and can obviously still bake, so maybe my brain is still working a little. :P

Peppermint Bark Deep Dish Cookie

Makes 6 servings
6 small ramekins (about 4″ diameter)
Candy Cane ice cream (see recipe)
Peppermint Bark Cookies (see recipe below)

Preheat oven to 375 F.

Fill ramekins 3/4″ deep with raw, room temperature cookie dough. Set ramekins on baking sheet and bake on the middle rack of the oven for 13-16 minutes, or until the top is just slightly golden brown. You’re aiming for slightly undercooked cookies.

Place ramekins on individual plates or napkins (they’ll be hot) and top with candy cane ice cream, as much or as little as you like.

These are best served straight from the oven.

Peppermint Bark Cookies
1 cup unsalted butter, at room temperature
1/2 cup granulated sugar
1 ½ cups brown sugar, packed
2 eggs
3 cups all-purpose flour
1 tsp. salt
1 tsp. baking powder
1/4 tsp. baking soda
2 cups peppermint bark, chopped in small pieces

In the bowl of electric mixer fitted with paddle attachment, cream together the butter and sugars until well blended and fluffy. Add eggs, one at a time and beat until well incorporated.

Into the bowl, add the flour, salt, baking soda, baking powder and mix until just combined. Gently fold in peppermint bark.

Adapted from Blue Eyed Bakers’.com


  1. Wow, this deep dish cookie looks absolutely fantastic. Especially sitting next to a first snuggled up with a blanket and eating it out of the dish :P Yum. Sorry about your cookies being left behind. It does “suck Christmas bulbs”, which is an awesome phrase by the way.

  2. that looks incredibly good!

  3. Sucks Christmas bulbs … that about says it all … until you turn up a peppermint bark deep dish cookies bowl like this, sort of lights up the night. LOVE peppermint ice cream, sort of sucks Christmas bulbs that it only turns up at Christmas.

  4. That is an interesting dessert! I’ve never had deep dish cookies.



  5. I wish they did more cookie exchanges over here! This deep dish cookie sounds so yummy…haven’t baked in TOO long!

  6. Cookie exchange sounds so fun! It’s a bummer that your cookies didn’t return home with you :(.

  7. You left cookies behind!!! How sad. Not only am I addicted to your site but you have me addicted to Pinerest too. Thanks and I will be making these this weekend.

  8. You’re really making me rethink my stance on mint in desserts. Since I was young I haven’t been a big fan, but every time you make something with the combination I really want to try it :).
    Besides, a deep dish cookie in any fashion sounds soooooo good, definitely a great way to make up for all those lost cookies (or anything else for that matter).

  9. I do stuff like that all of the time when I have to transport multiple items. I clearly need more bags to carry things. Or a personal valet.

  10. Love the idea of adding peppermint. Must try this!

  11. Christine says:

    Yum! I love peppermint and chocolate together! Got any suggestions of your fav cookies to take to a work cookie exchange?? I’m looking for something that looks festive, yet is still a classic! Thank you!

  12. These look so good!! Do you know if they would be ok just baked as regular cookies and not deep dish?

  13. I think you could make them just as cookies Shelly

Speak Your Mind


Log In