Butter and sugar (my two favorites)…

Nothing perks up my day more than someone emailing and asking me if I would like free butter. And not just any butter…Plugra. If you have ever baked with it you are filling up with jealousy and trying to find my house to rob me of my case (yes case) of Plugra. If you have never had it you are saying big deal.

The big deal is that it is European style meaning slow churned and therefore less moisture in the product. You get a creamier texture that produces a rich and wonderful flavor. Your cakes tend to rise higher and your pastry crusts (as my friend L found out when making pie crust with it) turn out flaky and as she put it the best pie crust she has ever tasted.

So yeah getting a case of it was a big deal. Now before you think oh my gosh how would you ever go through a case…I would. Easily…It’s 6 pounds of butter. I am already through half of it. It probably would be completely gone but I am being selective about what baked goods I am using it on. Peabody uses a lot of butter.

Take these simple sugar cookies for example. When a baked good is as simple as this you really want the ingredients to shine through. I have to make sugar cookies for Christmas every year as the dog wants them. :) Normally I just use regular sugar crystals but when I was at my parent’s house for Thanksgiving we were at a local shop that sells all things Huckleberry (very big in their area) and they had a huckleberry sugar. I bought some to try on sugar cookies. That turned out to be a very good idea.

These are great to make if you are like me and love sugar cookies but hate the roll out kind because that means rolling them out. :)
Disclaimer: if you didn’t catch on from the post Plugra was nice enough to send me a free case of butter to bake with.

Pin It


  1. I love sugar cookies and am always amazed at the simplicity of these classic recipes and how good they taste. My go-to recipe is hardly traditional as it uses vanilla pudding mix as an ingredient, but it maybe time to visit something new/old.
    I’ve never used Plugra (not sure if they sell it here) but we have similar butters that I never buy because they cost so much more. But if you’re telling me that it’s that different, then it might be time to splurge :).

  2. Lucky girl…a case of butter and slow-churned. Hello…sweet…butta’! I bet these cookies were heaven.

  3. @Adam- I hear ya on the cost. But I do usually have some in the house because it does indeed make a difference in texture and in flavor. I don’t use it on everything (I use butter from a wholesaler normally) but I wish I had the money to bake with it all the time. But when one bakes as much as I do that’s a bad financial choice. :)

  4. Our grocery has had plugra on sale for a couple weeks now, so Ive been using it exclusively. I dont know how I will go back to regular unsalted now. And thanks for the shout out. :)

  5. I made drop sugar cookies today, but I didn’t have huckleberry sugar. It sounds so interesting, and I now feel the need to track some of it down…

    But I’ve never heard of plurgra. We have kerrygold, which I guess may be similar? Maybe I dunno. I just use land o lakes :P

  6. Becca- kerygold is similar

  7. Jealous, jealous, jealous… ;)

  8. Darn you Peabody!!! I looked at the sugar online and bought the huckleberry one and a set of all the different flavors. Expensive but imagining all the yummy stuff I can make

  9. Trader joes used to carry Plugra butter. I cried the day they announced that they would no longer carry it. I still complain to the cashier about no Plugra. When I can find it I buy multi number of pounds, cut the block into quarters, wrap it up carefully and freeze the butter. That way I take out what I need for the immediate job without having to defrost the whole pound. I am jealous – 6 whole pounds? That is enough to die in butter plus.

  10. oh yes, totally green with envy here. I bought the stuff to do a cook’s illustrated recipe for croissants that specifically called for European butter and those were amazing.

Speak Your Mind


Log In